说课点评:说课环节:立足文本、清晰连贯、有理有据On the last day of the teaching contest, the finalists were given a 900-word reading passage and an AI-generated lesson plan to critique. Within half an hour, each contestant had to produce an analysis of the text, a critique of the AI-generated lesson plan, and a revised lesson plan of their own. Despite the tight timeframe, Xiaotong Chen handled the challenge remarkably well.Xiaotong began her presentation with a critique of the AI-generated lesson plan grounded in her students’ needs. Instead of going straight into the details of the lesson plan, she first considered its compatibility with her teaching setting—science and engineering students eager to read and write for research instead of passing CET-4/6. With their needs and motivation clarified, she then proceeded to critique one of the learning objectives, arguing that summarization might not be suitable for a news article profiling a scientist. She suggested that a research report that presented evidence-based reasoning for her students would be a better fit. She then evaluated several instructional activities, noting their communicative value (e.g., jigsaw reading), their irrelevance (e.g., sentence-structure analysis detached from textual comprehension), and their inauthenticity (e.g., interviewing an imagined character via AI instead of real researchers on campus). In short, Xiaotong’s emphasis on learner needs in reviewing the AI-generated lesson plan is commendable!Next, Xiaotong presented a coherent, thoughtful, and well-reasoned analysis of the text used in the proposed lesson plan. She reviewed the theme of the reading passage, explained its rhetorical patterns—an integrated narration-and-exposition structure—and identified some of the key language features in the text (e.g., language expressions used to present findings in an objective, academic tone). Her analysis was clearly pedagogically aligned with her students’ needs, and the brief genre-based analysis discussion was well calibrated to her teaching setting.With confidence, Xiaotong then presented her version of the lesson plan by redefining the learning goals—goals that moved beyond reading comprehension to viewing reading as a springboard to critical thinking and language communication. She organized the goals around three areas: thinking, competence, and knowledge. For thinking, she emphasized cultivating a spirit of scientific inquiry and developing a vision for future research. For competence, she outlined four objectives: a) comprehension—identifying the main character’s background and the significance of his scientific achievements; b) language ability—learning to describe someone’s academic achievements in descriptive language; c) AI integration to support research; and d) communication skills—especially narrating China stories effectively. For knowledge, she highlighted understanding the main ideas, learning evaluative expressions, and language structures for narration. Despite the need to elaborate on some of the goals, they clearly reflected her effort to help her students develop an ability to transfer their academic reading and thinking skills to their disciplinary studies.In the end, Xiaotong presented a reading lesson plan to demonstrate how she would redesign a section of the AI-generated lesson plan, one that focused students on both learning to read and reading to learn. In the pre-reading stage, students would engage in learning key technical terms while activating background knowledge. The during-reading stage focused on main-idea comprehension. The post-reading stage then engaged students in learning evaluative expressions for describing academic achievements, connecting the story to their academic pursuits, applying insights to their future research, and writing a feature story about a scientist who was a role model to them. Her intention to link the reading to students’ academic development and communication skills was evident. Without a doubt, students would be highly engaged in such a lesson, reading to think, connect, and communicate.改进建议While Xiaotong demonstrated strong teaching expertise, several aspects of her analysis and design could be further refined. Her critique of the AI-generated lesson plan could be strengthened by first identifying its underlying instructional design (e.g., comprehension—interpretation—exploration—communication) before noting specific inconsistencies. Her evaluation would also gain clarity by examining more explicitly how well the AI-generated model of instruction and its activities addressed the stated goals and objectives, as well as how effectively the activities scaffolded student learning. In explaining her own lesson plan, her presentation would be more coherent if she articulated the overall instructional design of the four-part lesson before discussing a selected section.点评专家:梁建松