﻿WEBVTT

00:00:12.074 --> 00:00:16.530
So there's this thing called
the law of unintended consequences.

00:00:17.022 --> 00:00:18.758
I thought it was just like a saying,

00:00:18.098 --> 00:00:19.674
but it actually exists, I guess.

00:00:20.058 --> 00:00:21.150
There's, like, academic papers about it.

00:00:22.094 --> 00:00:23.350
And I'm a designer.

00:00:24.022 --> 00:00:26.878
I don't like unintended consequences.

00:00:27.001 --> 00:00:31.577
People hire me because they have
consequences that they really intend,

00:00:31.007 --> 00:00:34.863
and what they intend is for me
to help them achieve those consequences.

00:00:35.058 --> 00:00:38.074
So I live in fear
of unintended consequences.

00:00:38.062 --> 00:00:42.130
And so this is a story about
consequences intended and unintended.

00:00:43.009 --> 00:00:46.145
I got called by an organization
called Robin Hood

00:00:47.006 --> 00:00:48.582
to do a favor for them.

00:00:48.066 --> 00:00:51.482
Robin Hood is based in New York,
a wonderful philanthropic organization

00:00:52.001 --> 00:00:53.737
that does what it says in the name.

00:00:53.086 --> 00:00:55.862
They take from rich people,
give it to poor people.

00:00:56.066 --> 00:01:00.962
In this case, what they wanted to benefit
was the New York City school system,

00:01:01.058 --> 00:01:06.394
a huge enterprise that educates
more than a million students at a time,

00:01:06.094 --> 00:01:08.430
and in buildings that are like this one,

00:01:09.003 --> 00:01:10.899
old buildings, big buildings,

00:01:11.022 --> 00:01:14.158
drafty buildings, sometimes buildings
that are in disrepair,

00:01:14.038 --> 00:01:16.574
certainly buildings
that could use a renovation.

00:01:16.094 --> 00:01:19.350
Robin Hood had this ambition
to improve these buildings in some way,

00:01:20.022 --> 00:01:21.478
but what they realized was

00:01:21.007 --> 00:01:25.543
to fix the buildings would be
too expensive and impractical.

00:01:26.026 --> 00:01:30.402
So instead they tried to figure out
what one room they could go into

00:01:30.066 --> 00:01:33.122
in each of these buildings,
in as many buildings that they could,

00:01:33.074 --> 00:01:35.730
and fix that one room

00:01:36.042 --> 00:01:38.858
so that they could improve
the lives of the children inside

00:01:39.026 --> 00:01:40.242
as they were studying.

00:01:40.005 --> 00:01:42.421
And what they came up with
was the school library,

00:01:42.094 --> 00:01:45.030
and they came up with this idea
called the Library Initiative.

00:01:45.009 --> 00:01:47.385
All the students
have to pass through the library.

00:01:48.003 --> 00:01:49.339
That's where the books are.

00:01:49.066 --> 00:01:51.402
That's where the heart
and soul of the school is.

00:01:52.002 --> 00:01:53.418
So let's fix these libraries.

00:01:53.046 --> 00:01:55.582
So they did this wonderful thing
where they brought in

00:01:56.002 --> 00:01:59.098
first 10, then 20, then more architects,

00:01:59.014 --> 00:02:02.750
each one of whom was assigned a library
to rethink what a library was.

00:02:02.009 --> 00:02:04.065
They trained special librarians.

00:02:04.098 --> 00:02:06.154
So they started this mighty enterprise

00:02:07.006 --> 00:02:10.022
to reform public schools
by improving these libraries.

00:02:10.001 --> 00:02:13.657
Then they called me up and they said,
"Could you make a little contribution?"

00:02:13.078 --> 00:02:15.094
I said, "Sure, what do you want me to do?"

00:02:15.082 --> 00:02:17.938
And they said, "Well, we want you
to be the graphic designer

00:02:18.007 --> 00:02:19.463
in charge of the whole thing."

00:02:20.018 --> 00:02:23.594
And so I thought, I know what that means.
That means I get to design a logo.

00:02:23.078 --> 00:02:25.094
I know how to design that. I design logos.

00:02:25.082 --> 00:02:26.738
That's what people come to me for.

00:02:27.005 --> 00:02:29.101
So OK, let's design a logo for this thing.

00:02:29.062 --> 00:02:31.318
Easy to do, actually,
compared with architecture

00:02:31.009 --> 00:02:32.265
and being a librarian.

00:02:33.018 --> 00:02:35.754
Just do a logo, make a contribution,
and then you're out,

00:02:35.094 --> 00:02:37.030
and you feel really good about yourself.

00:02:37.009 --> 00:02:40.785
And I'm a great guy and I like to feel
good about myself when I do these favors.

00:02:41.007 --> 00:02:42.583
So I thought, let's overdeliver.

00:02:43.003 --> 00:02:45.939
I'm going to give you three logos,
all based on this one idea.

00:02:46.026 --> 00:02:48.362
So you have three options,
pick any of the three.

00:02:48.062 --> 00:02:49.358
They're all great, I said.

00:02:49.094 --> 00:02:52.310
So the basic idea was
these would be new school libraries

00:02:53.018 --> 00:02:54.554
for New York schools,

00:02:54.074 --> 00:02:57.930
and so the idea is that it's a new thing,
a new idea that needs a new name.

00:02:58.062 --> 00:03:03.078
What I wanted to do was dispel the idea
that these were musty old libraries,

00:03:03.066 --> 00:03:06.682
the kind of places
that everyone is bored with,

00:03:07.003 --> 00:03:08.979
you know, not your grandparents' library.

00:03:09.003 --> 00:03:10.459
Don't worry about that at all.

00:03:10.078 --> 00:03:12.094
This is going to this new, exciting thing,

00:03:12.082 --> 00:03:13.338
not a boring library.

00:03:14.001 --> 00:03:15.657
So option number one:

00:03:15.078 --> 00:03:17.094
so instead of thinking of it as a library,

00:03:17.082 --> 00:03:21.258
think of it as a place where it is like:
do talk, do make loud noises.

00:03:22.002 --> 00:03:26.018
Right? So no shushing,
it's like a shush-free zone.

00:03:26.006 --> 00:03:28.182
We're going to call it the Reading Room.

00:03:28.026 --> 00:03:31.402
That was option number one.
OK, option number two.

00:03:31.066 --> 00:03:34.482
Option number two was, wait for it,

00:03:35.001 --> 00:03:36.257
OWL.

00:03:36.038 --> 00:03:37.374
I'll meet you at OWL.

00:03:37.074 --> 00:03:40.370
I'm getting my book from the OWL.
Meet you after school down at OWL.

00:03:41.006 --> 00:03:43.342
I like that, right?
Now, what does OWL stand for?

00:03:43.042 --> 00:03:44.938
Well, it could be One World Library,

00:03:45.034 --> 00:03:47.650
or it could be Open. Wonder. Learn.

00:03:47.098 --> 00:03:51.594
Or it could be -- and I figure librarians
could figure out other things it could be

00:03:52.005 --> 00:03:53.461
because they know about words.

00:03:53.098 --> 00:03:54.314
So other things, right?

00:03:55.022 --> 00:03:57.478
And then look at this.
It's like the eye of the owl.

00:03:57.007 --> 00:03:58.703
This is irresistible in my opinion.

00:03:59.042 --> 00:04:00.498
But there's even another idea.

00:04:00.009 --> 00:04:01.225
Option number three.

00:04:02.014 --> 00:04:04.630
Option number three
was based actually on language.

00:04:04.078 --> 00:04:07.374
It's the idea that "read"
is the past tense of "read,"

00:04:08.001 --> 00:04:09.857
and they're both spelled the same way.

00:04:09.098 --> 00:04:12.034
So why don't we call
this place The Red Zone?

00:04:12.094 --> 00:04:13.523
I'll meet you at the Red Zone.

00:04:14.393 --> 00:04:16.449
Are you Red? Get Red.

00:04:17.007 --> 00:04:18.223
I'm well Red.

00:04:18.094 --> 00:04:19.310
(Laughter)

00:04:20.018 --> 00:04:21.354
I really loved this idea,

00:04:21.054 --> 00:04:23.390
and I somehow was not focused on the idea

00:04:23.009 --> 00:04:28.905
that librarians as a class are sort of
interested in spelling and I don't know.

00:04:29.082 --> 00:04:31.017
(Laughter)

00:04:31.779 --> 00:04:35.276
But sometimes cleverness
is more important than spelling,

00:04:35.003 --> 00:04:37.419
and I thought this would be
one of those instances.

00:04:37.074 --> 00:04:39.090
So usually when I make these presentations

00:04:39.078 --> 00:04:41.854
I say there's just one question
and the question should be,

00:04:42.058 --> 00:04:43.434
"How can I thank you, Mike?"

00:04:43.098 --> 00:04:45.714
But in this case,
the question was more like,

00:04:46.062 --> 00:04:48.478
"Um, are you kidding?"

00:04:49.006 --> 00:04:50.702
Because, they said,

00:04:50.078 --> 00:04:51.454
the premise of all this work

00:04:52.018 --> 00:04:56.154
was that kids were bored
with old libraries, musty old libraries.

00:04:56.034 --> 00:04:57.250
They were tired of them.

00:04:57.058 --> 00:05:00.394
And instead, they said, these kids
have never really seen a library.

00:05:00.094 --> 00:05:01.910
The school libraries in these schools

00:05:02.078 --> 00:05:05.494
are really so dilapidated,
if they're there at all,

00:05:06.022 --> 00:05:07.958
that they haven't bored anyone.

00:05:08.018 --> 00:05:10.994
They haven't even been there
to bore anyone at all.

00:05:11.018 --> 00:05:14.434
So the idea was, just forget
about giving it a new name.

00:05:14.062 --> 00:05:18.118
Just call it, one last try, a library.

00:05:18.007 --> 00:05:19.223
Right? OK.

00:05:19.094 --> 00:05:21.950
So I thought, OK, give it a little oomph?

00:05:22.082 --> 00:05:23.298
Exclamation point?

00:05:24.006 --> 00:05:25.982
Then -- this is because I'm clever --

00:05:26.006 --> 00:05:28.542
move that into the "i,"

00:05:28.062 --> 00:05:29.318
make it red,

00:05:29.009 --> 00:05:31.185
and there you have it,
the Library Initiative.

00:05:32.001 --> 00:05:34.537
So I thought, mission accomplished,
there's your logo.

00:05:34.066 --> 00:05:37.122
So what's interesting about this logo,
an unintended consequence,

00:05:37.074 --> 00:05:40.210
was that it turned out that
they didn't really even need my design

00:05:40.009 --> 00:05:42.985
because you could type it any font,
you could write it by hand,

00:05:43.009 --> 00:05:45.105
and when they started
sending emails around,

00:05:46.002 --> 00:05:47.578
they just would use Shift and 1,

00:05:47.062 --> 00:05:49.638
they'd get their own logo
just right out of the thing.

00:05:50.022 --> 00:05:51.758
And I thought, well, that's fine.

00:05:51.098 --> 00:05:52.874
Feel free to use that logo.

00:05:53.078 --> 00:05:55.974
And then I embarked
on the real rollout of this thing --

00:05:56.007 --> 00:05:57.943
working with every one of the architects

00:05:58.066 --> 00:06:01.066
to put this logo on the front door
of their own library. Right?

00:06:02.018 --> 00:06:03.394
So here's the big rollout.

00:06:03.058 --> 00:06:05.314
Basically I'd work
with different architects.

00:06:05.086 --> 00:06:08.302
First Robin Hood was my client.
Now these architects were my client.

00:06:09.001 --> 00:06:11.240
I'd say, "Here's your logo.
Put it on the door."

00:06:11.363 --> 00:06:13.316
"Here's your logo. Put it on both doors."

00:06:13.034 --> 00:06:15.050
"Here's your logo.
Put it off to the side."

00:06:15.038 --> 00:06:17.294
"Here's your logo
repeated all over to the top."

00:06:17.066 --> 00:06:18.762
So everything was going swimmingly.

00:06:19.038 --> 00:06:21.694
I just was saying,
"Here's your logo. Here's your logo."

00:06:22.006 --> 00:06:24.142
Then I got a call
from one of the architects,

00:06:24.022 --> 00:06:26.878
a guy named Richard Lewis,
and he says, "I've got a problem.

00:06:27.001 --> 00:06:29.017
You're the graphics guy.
Can you solve it?"

00:06:29.014 --> 00:06:30.230
And I said, OK, sure."

00:06:30.038 --> 00:06:32.614
And he said, "The problem is
that there's a space

00:06:32.098 --> 00:06:33.914
between the shelf and the ceiling."

00:06:34.082 --> 00:06:36.418
So that sounds like
an architectural issue to me,

00:06:37.018 --> 00:06:39.114
not a graphic design issue,
so I'm, "Go on."

00:06:39.003 --> 00:06:42.659
And Richard says, "Well,
the top shelf has to be low enough

00:06:42.098 --> 00:06:43.314
for the kid to reach it,

00:06:44.022 --> 00:06:47.022
but I'm in a big old building,
and the ceilings are really high,

00:06:47.244 --> 00:06:49.316
so actually I've got
all this space up there

00:06:49.034 --> 00:06:50.730
and I need something like a mural."

00:06:51.006 --> 00:06:53.942
And I'm like, "Whoa,
you know, I'm a logo designer.

00:06:54.002 --> 00:06:56.138
I'm not Diego Rivera or something.

00:06:56.018 --> 00:06:57.634
I'm not a muralist."

00:06:57.082 --> 00:06:59.458
And so he said, "But can't you
think of anything?"

00:07:00.022 --> 00:07:05.398
So I said, "OK, what if we just
took pictures of the kids in the school

00:07:05.062 --> 00:07:07.518
and just put them around
the top of the thing,

00:07:08.001 --> 00:07:09.337
and maybe that could work."

00:07:09.046 --> 00:07:10.902
And my wife is a photographer,

00:07:11.034 --> 00:07:12.970
and I said, "Dorothy, there's no budget,

00:07:13.003 --> 00:07:16.179
can you come to this school
in east New York, take these pictures?"

00:07:16.005 --> 00:07:17.221
And she did,

00:07:17.074 --> 00:07:19.050
and if you go in Richard's library,

00:07:19.074 --> 00:07:20.930
which is one of the first that opened,

00:07:21.062 --> 00:07:24.158
it has this glorious frieze
of, like, the heroes of the school,

00:07:24.074 --> 00:07:25.770
oversized, looking down

00:07:26.046 --> 00:07:29.062
into the little dollhouse
of the real library, right?

00:07:29.005 --> 00:07:31.821
And the kids were great,
hand-selected by the principals

00:07:32.034 --> 00:07:33.810
and the librarian.

00:07:34.014 --> 00:07:37.270
It just kind of created
this heroic atmosphere in this library,

00:07:37.042 --> 00:07:40.538
this very dignified setting below
and the joy of the children above.

00:07:40.094 --> 00:07:44.430
So naturally all the other librarians
in the other schools see this

00:07:45.003 --> 00:07:46.939
and they said, well, we want murals too.

00:07:47.026 --> 00:07:48.322
And I'm like, OK.

00:07:48.058 --> 00:07:50.954
So then I think, well,
it can't be the same mural every time,

00:07:51.005 --> 00:07:54.061
so Dorothy did another one,
and then she did another one,

00:07:54.058 --> 00:07:55.674
but then we needed more help,

00:07:56.022 --> 00:07:58.878
so I called an illustrator I knew
named Lynn Pauley,

00:07:59.001 --> 00:08:01.937
and Lynn did these beautiful
paintings of the kids.

00:08:02.006 --> 00:08:06.342
Then I called a guy named Charles Wilkin
at a place called Automatic Design.

00:08:06.042 --> 00:08:07.050
He did these amazing collages.

00:08:08.078 --> 00:08:10.414
We had Rafael Esquer

00:08:11.014 --> 00:08:12.870
do these great silhouettes.

00:08:13.002 --> 00:08:15.178
He would work with the kids,
asking for words,

00:08:15.022 --> 00:08:16.598
and then based on those prompts,

00:08:16.082 --> 00:08:18.778
come up with this little,
delirious kind of constellation

00:08:19.054 --> 00:08:21.110
of silhouettes
of things that are in books.

00:08:21.062 --> 00:08:22.638
Peter Arkle interviewed the kids

00:08:23.022 --> 00:08:25.118
and had them talk
about their favorite books

00:08:25.034 --> 00:08:27.290
and he put their testimony
as a frieze up there.

00:08:27.062 --> 00:08:29.318
Stefan Sagmeister worked with Yuko Shimizu

00:08:29.009 --> 00:08:31.305
and they did this amazing
manga-style statement,

00:08:32.022 --> 00:08:34.478
"Everyone who is honest is interesting,"

00:08:34.007 --> 00:08:35.863
that goes all the way around.

00:08:36.058 --> 00:08:38.434
Christoph Niemann, brilliant illustrator,

00:08:38.098 --> 00:08:39.474
did a whole series of things

00:08:40.038 --> 00:08:43.054
where he embedded books
into the faces and characters

00:08:43.042 --> 00:08:46.178
and images and places
that you find in the books.

00:08:46.058 --> 00:08:48.097
And then even Maira Kalman

00:08:48.066 --> 00:08:51.881
did this amazing cryptic installation
of objects and words

00:08:52.499 --> 00:08:55.676
that kind of go all around
and will fascinate students

00:08:55.007 --> 00:08:56.583
for as long as it's up there.

00:08:57.003 --> 00:08:58.659
So this was really satisfying,

00:08:58.098 --> 00:09:03.994
and basically my role here was reading
a series of dimensions to these artists,

00:09:04.009 --> 00:09:05.265
and I would say,

00:09:06.018 --> 00:09:08.714
"Three feet by 15 feet, whatever you want.

00:09:08.009 --> 00:09:10.225
Let me know if you have
any problem with that."

00:09:11.014 --> 00:09:14.230
And they would go and install these.
It just was the greatest thing.

00:09:14.038 --> 00:09:16.334
But the greatest thing, actually, was --

00:09:16.007 --> 00:09:17.223
Every once in a while,

00:09:17.094 --> 00:09:20.310
I'd get, like, an invitation in the mail
made of construction paper,

00:09:21.018 --> 00:09:24.314
and it would say, "You are invited
to the opening of our new library."

00:09:24.005 --> 00:09:26.381
So you'd go to the library,
say, you'd go to PS10,

00:09:26.009 --> 00:09:27.225
and you'd go inside.

00:09:28.014 --> 00:09:30.790
There'd be balloons,
there'd be a student ambassador,

00:09:30.094 --> 00:09:32.230
there'd be speeches that were read,

00:09:33.001 --> 00:09:35.897
poetry that was written
specifically for the opening,

00:09:36.002 --> 00:09:38.938
dignitaries would present people
with certificates,

00:09:38.098 --> 00:09:40.714
and the whole thing
was just a delirious, fun party.

00:09:41.062 --> 00:09:42.678
So I loved going to these things.

00:09:43.026 --> 00:09:46.002
I would stand there dressed like this,
obviously not belonging,

00:09:46.026 --> 00:09:48.693
and someone would say,
"What are you doing here, mister?"

00:09:48.951 --> 00:09:52.116
And I'd say, "Well, I'm part of the team
that designed this place."

00:09:52.014 --> 00:09:53.919
And they'd said, "You do these shelves?"

00:09:54.069 --> 00:09:56.476
And I said, "No."
"You took the pictures up above."

00:09:56.005 --> 00:09:57.221
"No."

00:09:57.074 --> 00:09:58.290
"Well, what did you do?"

00:09:58.098 --> 00:10:00.554
"You know when you came in?
The sign over the door?"

00:10:01.046 --> 00:10:02.462
"The sign that says library?"

00:10:02.009 --> 00:10:03.025
(Laughter)

00:10:03.094 --> 00:10:04.310
"Yeah, I did that!"

00:10:05.018 --> 00:10:09.030
And then they'd sort of go,
"OK. Nice work if you can get it."

00:10:10.002 --> 00:10:14.098
So it was so satisfying
going to these little openings

00:10:14.014 --> 00:10:17.750
despite the fact that I was
kind of largely ignored or humiliated,

00:10:17.009 --> 00:10:19.185
but it was actually fun
going to the openings,

00:10:20.001 --> 00:10:22.697
so I decided that I wanted
to get the people in my office

00:10:22.082 --> 00:10:25.538
who had worked on these projects,
get the illustrators and photographers,

00:10:26.003 --> 00:10:27.699
and I said, why don't we rent a van

00:10:28.002 --> 00:10:30.378
and drive around
the five boroughs of New York

00:10:30.042 --> 00:10:32.058
and see how many we could hit at one time.

00:10:32.046 --> 00:10:34.902
And eventually there were
going to be 60 of these libraries,

00:10:35.034 --> 00:10:38.810
so we probably got to see
maybe half a dozen in one long day.

00:10:39.014 --> 00:10:41.950
And the best thing of all
was meeting these librarians

00:10:42.001 --> 00:10:45.577
who kind of were running these,
took possession of these places

00:10:45.007 --> 00:10:47.583
like their private stage
upon which they were invited

00:10:48.003 --> 00:10:51.939
to mesmerize their students
and bring the books to life,

00:10:52.026 --> 00:10:54.562
and it was just
this really exciting experience

00:10:54.082 --> 00:10:56.898
for all of us to actually
see these things in action.

00:10:57.066 --> 00:10:59.602
So we spent a long day doing this

00:11:00.022 --> 00:11:01.838
and we were in the very last library.

00:11:02.006 --> 00:11:04.822
It was still winter,
because it got dark early,

00:11:04.009 --> 00:11:05.225
and the librarian says,

00:11:06.014 --> 00:11:08.710
"I'm about to close down.
So really nice having you here.

00:11:08.086 --> 00:11:11.222
Hey, wait a second, do you want to see
how I turn off the lights?"

00:11:12.002 --> 00:11:13.298
I'm like, "OK."

00:11:13.034 --> 00:11:15.530
And she said, "I have
this special way that I do it."

00:11:15.086 --> 00:11:16.342
And then she showed me.

00:11:17.014 --> 00:11:20.470
What she did was she turned out
every light one by one by one by one,

00:11:20.062 --> 00:11:22.118
and the last light she left on

00:11:22.007 --> 00:11:24.903
was the light that illuminated
the kids' faces,

00:11:25.062 --> 00:11:27.918
and she said, "That's the last light
I turn off every night,

00:11:28.005 --> 00:11:30.581
because I like to remind myself
why I come to work."

00:11:31.001 --> 00:11:33.857
So when I started this whole thing,

00:11:33.098 --> 00:11:35.289
remember, it was just
about designing that logo

00:11:36.195 --> 00:11:38.196
and being clever, come up with a new name?

00:11:38.022 --> 00:11:39.598
The unintended consequence here,

00:11:39.082 --> 00:11:40.898
which I would like to take credit for

00:11:41.066 --> 00:11:44.282
and like to think I can think through
the experience to that extent,

00:11:44.009 --> 00:11:45.225
but I can't.

00:11:46.014 --> 00:11:49.990
I was just focused on a foot ahead of me,
as far as I could reach with my own hands.

00:11:50.014 --> 00:11:52.590
Instead, way off in the distance

00:11:52.074 --> 00:11:53.330
was a librarian

00:11:54.002 --> 00:11:56.938
who was going to find
the chain of consequences

00:11:56.098 --> 00:11:57.514
that we had set in motion,

00:11:58.042 --> 00:11:59.538
a source of inspiration

00:11:59.094 --> 00:12:02.470
so that she in this case
could do her work really well.

00:12:03.034 --> 00:12:06.410
40,000 kids a year
are affected by these libraries.

00:12:06.074 --> 00:12:08.530
They've been happening
for more than 10 years now,

00:12:09.022 --> 00:12:13.558
so those librarians have kind of turned on
a generation of children to books

00:12:13.078 --> 00:12:15.574
and so it's been a thrill to find out

00:12:16.003 --> 00:12:19.739
that sometimes unintended consequences
are the best consequences.

00:12:20.006 --> 00:12:21.222
Thank you very much.

00:12:21.003 --> 00:12:24.091
(Applause)
